Unusual Tales", a series presenting Steve Ditko's comics from 1957 to 1959 that are in the public domain.
This starts off as a typical "small village misunderstands and persecutes the outsider who moves into that mysterious mountain-top house on the outskirts of town" story, but has one of the weirdest twists to such a story I've ever seen. Very well told by Ditko, capturing the angry mob nicely.
Some links to check out:
Buy Ditko's creator-owned work
Many classic books available
Find out about the fanzine DITKOMANIA
New issue, focus on later Marvel work, out soon
Check out new and upcoming Ditko publications
Spider-Man reprint with full issue of pencil photocopies available
Download public domain comics, likely including the one this story is from
scans in this series generally adapted to my personal tastes from those copies
Click images to learn the truth